Best Places to Eat in Dufferin County

Twenty-five years ago, Italian-born owner Mario Adamo had a hunch that the Hockley Valley hills might be grape country. He was right. Adamo now grows 28,000 biodynamic vines across 77 acres with real character in every bottle. The food is Italian — gnocchi, risotto, bruschetta. This summer, stay for alfresco movie nights in the vines. One of Dufferin County’s most special experiences.

Orangeville’s landmark dining destination set in a beautifully restored historic building. Great burgers, Ontario craft beers, and a lively atmosphere any night of the week. Also serves as a premier event venue — home to the Dufferin Film Festival’s VIP Social.

Consistently Orangeville’s most talked-about restaurant. Scratch-made pasta, wood-fired pizzas with hot honey, fresh daily cheesecakes, and a menu that changes with what’s good. Family-owned — the owner visits every table. Packs out on weeknights. Reservations strongly recommended.

A British couple relocated from England to Marsville and brought something Dufferin County didn’t have: Deluxe New York Style cookies with deep-filled centres sourced straight from the UK, plus cruffins — the croissant-muffin hybrid best enjoyed warm with a scoop of ice cream. Everything is made with a very specific level of obsession. The brick-and-mortar on County Road 3 opened in 2025 and is now welcoming walk-ins. Also found at the Kitchener Market on Saturdays.

Cozy Broadway café and roastery with specialty coffee, lunch, and cocktails. Friendly staff, fair prices, and one of the most inviting spots on the main strip. A Culinary Passport participant — grab your stamp here.

Cozy bistro celebrating local and seasonal ingredients. Upstairs wine room is ideal for groups of 6. Known for excellent swordfish, salmon, and spinach dip. One of Orangeville’s most beloved dinner spots — worth the drive from anywhere in the county.

Pastéis de nata and malassadas are the standout nods to the owner’s Portuguese heritage. Excellent sandwiches, gourmet grilled cheese, and baked goods that sell out early. A must-stop on any Orangeville food crawl.

Famous for creative shortbread flavours — including lavender — made with real care. Located next to the municipal parking lot on Broadway. A lovely gift shop and an easy sweet stop between Broadway errands.